The equality of women in the workplace has been an important and debated issue forever. Today, even in an industry as progressive as advertising, most ad agencies fall way short of fair hiring and promotion practices.
This is blatantly apparent to any reader reviewing the work and the credentials of the winners posted monthly in Creativity magazine, a sister publication to Advertising Age. While the editor is female, there is seldom a woman’s name attributed to any campaign, awarded ad, spot, or Agency of the Year lineup of principals. In a year, you can count on one hand, the number of women even mentioned.
According to DIMA@NYU quoting AdAge.com, (“Human Rights Commission Releases Agencies’ Minority Hiring Goals,” 2007), on January 11, 2007, 15 advertising agencies in New York City released the first set of goals pledged to increase minority hiring and retention. They were all major ad agencies. This pledge was the result of The New York City Commission on Human Rights’ probe into their hiring practices. However, there was no definition of minority and each agency chose their own percentage of minorities to be hired—all different numbers.
“One agency executive said the working definition is ‘non-white’ (meaning that white women won’t count toward the goal).” Huh?
This is only the tip of the iceberg. When it’s an industry that caters heavily to women consumers and a city as progressive as New York being held accountable, there’s definitely more to uncover here. I find it fascinating that this is the status quo today, when skilled men are growing older, fewer men than women are entering college, and women in the workforce are younger and represent a large percentage of the employed.
In the ’70s and ’80s, in response to the glass ceiling, it became the thing for women to found their own ad agencies, doing some of the most pioneering advertising that’s ever been created. Adrienne Hall (who just passed away on February 7), Joan Levine (Adrienne’s partner), Janet Marie Carlson, Mary Wells Lawrence (first person to take an ad agency public)–these were my mentors as I opened my little-shop-that-could in LA. But the boys were my inspiration. The boys who would hire me, but wouldn’t give me the title or tithe to go with the talent. So I gave it to myself and Medlin & Associates was born. I loved that baby and it grew to be a thing of beauty.
Gender discrimination is happening at some of our biggest and best companies, too. According to the Global Learning Resources, Inc. web site (“No Women at Apple’s Top?” 2007), “Over 77% of women between the ages of 35 and 44 are working today, versus about 39% in 1950. Similar increases are found at every age level. It should be the dawn of the age of women if you look at the impressive statistics and trends.” But company employment statistics prove otherwise.
In 2008, when the first woman ever is running for president of the United States of America, surely there should be more CEOs and CDs named Shirley.